PDA

View Full Version : Algebraic conumdrum


Ghoulish Delight
08-31-2005, 08:04 AM
I've managed to stump myself with a seemingly straight forward problem. Find all valid solutions for a and b in the following expression:

a*b=a

Now, at first the solution is obvious. b=a/a, b=1. So the set of soultions is:

a={all numbers}
b={1}

So far so good. However, a quick, non-algebraic analysis of the expression clearly shows there is another solution set, namely:

a={0}
b={all numbers}

So why can't I get the expression to yield that solution algebraicly? It's obvious looking at it, but I can't find a systematic way of solving the equation to get a=0. What am I missing (and am I going to feel really stupid when someone points it out to me)?

mousepod
08-31-2005, 08:22 AM
Algebraically speaking, I'd say that the first solution is the correct one, except in the case where a=0.

0 divided by 0 is considered "undefined" because it poses a conflict between two rules.