I just re-read the GN for the first time in 20 years. While I have no doubt that the story as written is superior as a comic - I'm thinking that my initial judgement of the movie might have been harsh. As I read the GN, I would consider "How would I film this scene?" - I think that Snyder probably did a better job than most directors would have.

I will certainly revisit the film when it comes out on blu-(penis) ray.