Yeah, left the boat behind once they were on Gilligan's Island, or whatever that neighbor island is called. How would Desmond get there from the Mystery Island? Um, he's kind of a major character. They had just had a scene where they pulled him up by a rope. Oh, but Hurley screamed "No" when he realized it wasn't Jack. Did he throw him back down?? Is that the kind of Jacob he's gonna be??


Anyway, Very.Sloppy.

That would be hysterical. Hurley is the new Ben-Flocke-Jacob combo.

ETA: It's fun to go back and read through the beginning of this thread....from May/June of 2005 at the end of season 1.

I don't think it was sloppy, I think it was purposely indeterminate. The answer lies in the Ben and Hurley Variety Hour. He remained on the island, trying to get off, with the help of Hurley as the new #1 (btw, I'm assuming the "#2", "#1" exchange was a nod to The Prisoner), all the while dealing with new arrivals, helping the ones who deserve it and deciding if any of them are worthy of taking over for Hurley so that he can die and join everyone else.

I was trying to figure out the whole tree falling on that guy thing. He looked like he was squished but he was really fine.

All the falling rocks reminded me of the classic Star Trek TV series.

Half answered.
Does that mean Rose and Bernard died when the island was destroyed? I know that Desmond obtained Floke's "word" that he would leave them alone.
Kinda answered in the recap - they turned into easter eggs.
Answered.

An early report...
13.5 million watch "Lost" finale
I was expecting a whole lot more...
Hmm.

I still don't get what you're referring to as a disappearance. They pulled him up and the next time they show Ben and Hurley, Desmond is lying unconscious on the ground. That's when Ben says Desmond's going to be ok, etc as I mentioned above. Is there a scene with those guys after that that I'm forgetting?

I was a little taken aback at Hurley's reaction to seeing Desmond instead of Jack. If the line were just "Desmond?" instead of "NO!" it wouldn't make him seem as bad.

Speaking of Bigfoot - GD pointed out to me that Hurley doesn't really have any flaws, so how is mixed up in all this mess anyway?

I like 98% of what this guy says.

Unneccessarily Censored LOST

Don't all Hawaiian residents get a copy? Like the oil money in Alaska?

I suppose his flaw is allowing himself to become controlled by his belief in "the curse", an inability to take responsibility for making the best of his life despite any bad luck he might have. Still seems like a weak flaw compared to everyone else's.

Very well written review.
http://chud.com/articles/articles/23...ING/Page1.html

Ah, thanks, CP. I didn't remember he was seen lying unconscious and they made a remark about it. And I guess I didn't read your earlier post clearly enough.


BTD: How was Island Underwater answered? We were left puzzling about that. Some people said that's just how it was in the sideways universe. But if the sideways universe is simply a matrix limbo where no one even KNOWS ABOUT the Island, how is the Island somehow underwater?