I haven't see it yet. But I'm glad to see John Ratzenberger has a role. I think the only really good Pixar movies are the ones that have John Ratzenberger in them.

Ummm....

Just saw this movie....excellent flick! Cried only once, but was expecting that considering what everyone has said.

So you like them all with the exception of the shorts and Ratatouille?

Ratzenberger was in Ratatouille.

And shorts don't count as movies.

I saw Up a couple days ago and I loved it. Not as much as some, like Wall E, but still a great film. Partly Cloudy was ok, but probably one of my least favorite Pixar Shorts.

Saw it again this weekend in 3D.

Unlike most here, I felt it played well the second time. Sure, it didn't have the same emotional impact as it did the first time, but the second time around some things that bugged me the first time (like the big fight scene) didn't bug me this time.

Also caught some things I hadn't noticed the first time - like the dog with an Ace up his collar...

Loved looking at all the detail in background, the wistful look of the window washer, the textures of the ties, Carl's developing stubble....it's a great movie. Still probably my favorite Pixar.

Do you think the 3D added a lot? Prefer it either way?

Honestly, beyond the first couple scenes I didn't really notice the 3D, so I'm not sure I even have a preference. Probably prefer the 3D because the cool moments are pretty cool.