Because I thought about it too late. If some moderator wants to moderate and make it a poll they can feel free to do so.

you noticed...

c'mon man, cigars and brandy on the patio. :cheers:

#2.
#1 is going to make your feet look big.
imho

:)

I like Recital, which I think is #1. But I have smallish feet, so clunky shoes work for me. (?)

#2

#2, they look more graceful.

Recital - they look more "Gothic Lolita" :D

I could always return the tan oxfords and get both...

Ok, clearly a day late to this, but I like the second ones with the double strap better. (But, I have big feet so tend to shy away from clunky shoes when given an alternative.)

Ok, I'm going for the Delectable. I found them in 4 different colors. I am really leaning towards the olive green since I have a ton of black shoes and several pair of chocolate shoes.

These are like the oxfords I bought, but they are solid tan.