Well, other than the dis of David Sedaris, I am completely in agreement with you on type of comedy I respond to. For me, Sedaris has such strange powers of observing the absurd, which is one of the things I find funny. There are times when Woody Allen fits into this broad generalization and I greatly enjoy him at those times as well.

As far as AFI's list, there are films on the list I absolutely LOVE but I don't think of them as "comedies" in the strict sense. My list would include:

The Philadelphia Story
Arsenic and Old Lace
Sullivan's Travels
The Lady Eve (Love Sturges)
The Thin Man
Fargo and
Groundhog Day

When pressed to find other films that make me laugh, Whit Stillman comes to mind (Barcelona has scenes which kill me every time), but I also like Gilliam's Brazil but, again, it is absurdist.

Now, the common argument is that, if I like the absurd, why don't I like Python? I don't know. I find it annoying. I prefer the comedy to sneak into a scene in a subtle way rather than be hit over the head with it.

The comment I always get is that, it is odd that someone who laughes so often is not a fan of comedy.

Odd is somebody who laughs at anything shoved their way just because somebody else said it's funny.

I don't find anything even remotely funny about Rodney Dangerfeild.

I never found any of his scripted appearances funny (though the Triple Lindy has a certain genius). But my step father had a couple of his (very) old LPs when I was growing up and there was some very funny stuff on them.

I find David Sedaris to be very funny. But some of his material isn't meant to be. Love him.

I don't necessarily classify what's funny and what isn't and then analyze the crud out of it. If I did that, nothing would be funny.

I'm not a big Eddie Murphy fan, but I loved the two table scenes in 'The Nutty Professor'. Completely "low brow" but I loved it all the same.

'Bringing Up Baby' is hysterical. It's all silly and slapstick and I love that. Is it a perfect film, no. Is it repeatable? Yes. Is it fun to watch stuffy Cary Grant slide down a hill on his ass and then fall into a river with Kate Hepburn, totally.

A movie I love is 'Defending Your Life'. Albert Brooks is often funny. I guess it's "high-brow" but who cares. Funny is funny. Shirley McLaine's appearance in that film is classic. Not to mention Meryl Streep, she throws away half of her lines and they're still brilliant.

I find 'Young Frankenstein' to be a great film. It's a homage to old b/w horror films and it's funny in many, many places. Madeline Kahn is extremely funny in that.

I watched "Jersey Girl" last night. It's not funny.

I hope you didn't actually pay to see it. Affleck blows!

Not surprised. That explains that winning smile of Matt Damon's...
:D :evil:

I find David Sedaris funny when he is talking but, for me, all that seems to go away once he has written it down. And his sister is many times more funny than he is.

I also don't tend to analyze what is funny and what is not. It isn't like you can control what you find funny. But I was asked.

Sedaris has a great voice. And, of course, when he's impersonating his brother, that's hysterical. I find his writings funny, though.

Amy Sedaris is hysterical. They should cast her in more films.