I loved all three POTC films. It's a great trilogy, and should be left at that.

Did Disney learn nothing from Lucas's horrible mistake of a second trilogy?

So, I wonder what/who will be the Jar Jar Binks sidekick in POTC 4? I think they should introduce a Macken (half man, half cracken) that turns out to be Jack's love child resulting from his earlier momentary soirée with the beast. He should be completely CG, and voiced by Jeff Foxworthy, so it can imply that all inter-beast lovers are from the South.

Oh dear, the moment Jack has a kid, the series has truly jumped the shark. Even for Pirates.

It makes me wonder what dirt Disney has on Depp that they can blackmail him to do these roles.

They made him an offer he couldn't refuse. Ka-Ching

Johnny Depp's turned money-whore, he be. So says I, Chernabog Jones.

yah, you'd think he'd turned Pirate or somethin

:argghh:

Pirates 1 great. Pirates 2 ok. Pirates 3 sucked. Sorry i couldn't even finish watching it all the way thru the few times i tried. Thank goodness i didn't go to a theater to see it. I might try to sit down and watch it one more time. Pirates 4 i don't think so. Makes me wonder what Disney has on Jonny to get him to do another movie. Ah to be a fly on the wall. If only.

Since no one else seemed to watch 3 to the end. They left it wide open for Capt Jack to go find the fountain of youth.

I watched POTC 3 all the way until the end. I even waited after the credits to see Will Turner return to Elizabeth and their son.



(Actually we were just waiting for everyone to leave. So we saw that part by accident) ;p

I'll go see a fourth Pirates movie if the running time is an hour and forty five minutes or less. (preferably less.) All three Pirates movies are bloated length-wise. The first one gets away with it by being better than it needed to be. (It would be better still if it lost about twenty minutes or so.) I can't make the same allowance for the other two. They overstayed their welcomes by over 60 minutes each.

And that third one was just a mess.