Here's what I made and how it turned out:
Cranberry sauce - used Heidi's recipe above. So simple and delicious. Everyone was amazed at how good cranberry sauce tastes when it isn't from a can.
Stuffing - Used MF's recipe above, minus the apple. Pretty decent, gone by the end of the night.
Rolls - Tried Heidi's super complicated roll recipe above, didn't find them horribly complicated, but also didn't think they were the best roll I ever had. I might have done something wrong. I think I cooked them a bit too long. Everyone loved them and gobbled them up. Heidi, seriously, ya could have warned me that they come out shaped like vulvas.
Pies- Made pumpkin streusal pies from a cookbook I got from the Library called Vegetarian Celebrations. Pretty darn good. For Xmas I'm going to make Heidi's pumpkin cheesecake.
Butternut Squash - So easy in the microwave! Really delicious too. Michael liked it!
Other than that it was a decent thanksgiving. That probably means something different to my family than to more functional groups, but hey, I'll take what I can get.