[katiesue]

I liked the book very much. The epilouge was a bit corny but at least you had some finality to it all.

I didn't like all the deaths off camera so to speak - Lupin, Tonks, Mad Eye. They deserved a little glory.

I wanted to know more about Luna and her dad. I had hoped that somehow they wern't bonkers and there really were all these mad creatures and plants out there. Or at the very least that perhaps Luna's mothers death had sent her dad over the edge. I also thought Luna and Neville would have been a great couple in the end.