Loving the ideas so far! Keep 'em coming! Except for that rotating thing.
We'll probably decide on a few different ones and then do a composite of sorts.
Here's the fireplace in its current state:
Since it's a rental property, we can't alter the face of it - just build around it. Otherwise, I would have LOVED the one JWBear posted. That's gorgeous!
The tiki one is fun, but a wee bit too big for the living room.
And, we're keeping tiki confined to the dining room still. We're trying to go more Middle Earth with the living room.