I feel much the same as "the LoT guys", just to throw a monkey wrench in the theory 
I can totally understand going with a gut reaction though.  Sometimes there's no denying it.  I really, really hate the term "women's intuition" though.  You never hear about "men's intuition", as if there's no such thing, or that women are more in touch with the Force somehow.
I do think that people are too jaded.  As a teen/twentysomething I quite often ran into similar situations, from the "freaky young person" perspective.  Remember 
this guy?  I would have totally done something like that.
Anyway, I wouldn't feel too bad, Helen, but I would definitely be more receptive next time.  

  (and Alex is right, he went about it the wrong way.)