View Single Post
Old 01-23-2009, 10:00 PM   #234
David E
Tethered
 
David E's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 64
David E is really wigging hereDavid E is really wigging hereDavid E is really wigging hereDavid E is really wigging hereDavid E is really wigging here
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ghoulish Delight View Post
BTW, that would be the leftist, secular, forces in Knesset that have made negotiation with Palestinians the predominant position of Israel. The right wing religious parties continue to insist that force is the only answer.
I didn't say they didn't think force might be necessary, only that they want a two-state solution and peace. As you say, they differ among themselves as to how to achieve that. The problem with this leftist ideal is that negotiation only works when both parties have a similar frame of reference/values. Gandhi and MLK's peaceful resistance worked with the British Empire and in the US because they were appealing to a common sense of decency of those regimes, whereas it would not have worked against a Hitler or at Tiannaman Square.

So too negotiation alone can't work with Hamas - what is there to negotiate when they want nothing less than the destruction of Israel (as they themselves say), and are willing to die for their cause?
__________________
David E.

The Best is the enemy of the Better.
David E is offline   Submit to Quotes Reply With Quote