View Single Post
Old 09-14-2009, 08:55 PM   #33
Ghoulish Delight
I Floop the Pig
 
Ghoulish Delight's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Alternative Swankstyle
Posts: 19,348
Ghoulish Delight is the epitome of coolGhoulish Delight is the epitome of coolGhoulish Delight is the epitome of coolGhoulish Delight is the epitome of coolGhoulish Delight is the epitome of coolGhoulish Delight is the epitome of coolGhoulish Delight is the epitome of coolGhoulish Delight is the epitome of coolGhoulish Delight is the epitome of coolGhoulish Delight is the epitome of coolGhoulish Delight is the epitome of cool
Send a message via AIM to Ghoulish Delight Send a message via Yahoo to Ghoulish Delight
I jus listebed to a really interesting piece from NPR's All Songs Cnsidered about this, an interview with someone involved in the profuction.

listen here

He starts with a discussion of what remastering is, what source material they used, and the things they decided to "fix" without ruining the integrity of the recordings. He played a shirt clip to demonstrate how they took an obvious recording error (backing vocal track dropping out for a moment) and fixed it the way the Beatles certainly would have if they had the capability. To be honest I listened 3 times and couldn really make out the difference. Such audio quality things are clearly lost on my ears.

More interesting to me was the discussion of the difference between the mono and stereo mixes. He focused on Sgt. Peppers which probably represents the biggest difference between the 2 sibce the Beatles themselves oversaw the mono mix while they left the stereo mix entirely to George Martin. The guy in the interview made a case for the mono mix being his preferred, and I'll say he was pretty persuasive. At the very least it certainly justifies the existence of both box sets from a completeness standpoint.

Well worth the 20 minute or so listen.
__________________
'He who receives an idea from me, receives instruction himself without lessening mine; as he who lights his taper at mine, receives light without darkening me.'
-TJ

Ghoulish Delight is offline   Submit to Quotes Reply With Quote