[bewitched]

There was just an article about debarking in the nyt. I agree, extremely inhumane.

Citronella collars aren't for everyone (or every breed). If they are set on sensitive, they can often inadvertently punish the dog when another dog barks near them. As with all behavior modification tools, they are most effective when combined with training.

In rereading my post, I meant to say my doggy psych uses Xanax (with or without an antidepressant) and/or behavior modification. (As opposed to always prescribing Xanax...which is how it sounded). Nonetheless, Xanax has worked wonders in some of my dogs.

As an aside, my mother swears by both Rescue Remedy and Calm Down! Personally, I have just never seen noticeable results, but of course, YMMV.