[Eliza Hodgkins 1812]

Spoiler:

Originally Posted by DisneyFan25863

Spoiler:

Yeah, the one thing that doesn't fit in is the Unbreakable Vow, unless Snape KNEW he was going to have to kill Dumbledore and do all of that so far in advance, which I doubt. Thats the only thing keeping me thinking that he may actually be evil...

Spoiler:

Actually, if he's good, I think he probably had to make the vow to secure his cover as a spy (remember, when first asked to make the vow, he hesitated at first, and then Lestrange was surprised when he actually did it). If he's good, everything he's done in this book was done to secure Voldemort's trust, and what better way than to make an unbreakable vow, to kill Dumbledore. If (BIG if) he's good, I assume the vow came first, and Snape immediately went to Dumbledore and said, "I've had to do this and now we have to figure out away around it. When it comes down to it, I may just have to stop Draco and let myself die." And Dumbledore might have said, "Well, there's the alternative. Save Draco, and kill me yourself. It may just benefit your place as a spy."

"But I can't do that!"

"You will do as I say. You've always promised you would."

Bah. BAH! There needs to be a fan pole. Those who say Snape is EVIL say aye, and those who think he's still working for the right say, say nay. I just...I'm torn. Obviously. Heh.