Quote:
	
	
		| 
			
				 
					Originally Posted by BarTopDancer
					
				 
				Betty and Sca, 
In Season 1 Hurley went through the manifest with the Beachies and everyone except Ethan was on it. 
			
		 | 
	
	
 Yes, but was he an other, or was he working with Danielle?  Remember, Claire remembered that she had to scratch Danielle to escape.  Why would Ethan, as an other, bring Claire to Danielle?