Personally, I'd go for Pajamas. But, I do love me a lovely pair of pajamas.
I get enthralled with little plush things on occasion, but I find they don't hold my interest for very long - except in the case of Berthold, my hippo. I LOVE Berthold.
Somehow, an indulgence in one of the fine botique choclatiers would make me happy.
Vosges is one that I adore, but there are others to explore.
But, overall, I'm not a big fan of Valentines Day. I prefer little lovey surprises throughout the year for no other reason than pure love.