Interesting. I never would have thought to report it to them, as I would have felt guilty about that as well. "Hey, I broke your merchandise, but as I prefer whole cookies I'm going to let your store eat it." I always thought "you break it, you buy it" was the standard line.
I did not mean to drop them, but I did. As I actually did want Oreos, it wasn't that much of a stretch for me to buy them. If I opened a package of broken cookies as a kid I would have been bummed.
Ah well, at least I erred on the side of caution
and these are fun to dunk.