Star Trek

[Cadaverous Pallor]

Originally Posted by iSm

I can't deny loving seeing him as Spock, but I think it dimmed the reboot that was otherwise going so successfully.

I agree that when he came back later it was too much, but I had a truly emotional moment when Spock talked about the old/real/alt universe. It was a passing of the torch that hit me in the gut. ymmv, of course.

What might have been with Shatner.

I think the voice over could have worked, and the birthday card could have worked too. I think I'd really dig the latter, and it might have given them a better reason to bring Nimoy back at the end.