Get It Off Your (Dead Man's) Chest: Pirates Movie Reviews

[Alex]

Originally Posted by innerSpaceman

But yeah, if a curse or magic also acts upon your clothing, for effect that is purely show and zero curse, I want that told to me.

That really makes no sense. You are shown how the curse works but it is only acceptable if some character looks at the audience and offers a lecture on the mechanics? To me that is like complaining that hyperspace engines are cartoon-physics mixed in with live action physics because Han Solo never pauses to explain how they work.

I also disagree that there is an explained underlying order to the Harry Potter world of magic. Maybe in the books there is, but not in the movies.

But it sounds like you're working yourself back into disliking Curse of the Black Pearl.