Even Worse Bus Ads: Britain Secularist Society

[€uroMeinke]

Originally Posted by David E

As you can see, I am arguing for good religion in general vs. secularism. I am not a fan of the emphasis on exclusivity that you point out. Having said that, of all of them I prefer the JC system as compared to the other 5 previously listed for the reasons I outlined.

I guess I'm stuck on the concept of "good" religion - that sort of gets stuck in a circular argument when each religion defines what's "good" making itself defacto good.

It seems for you to even evaluate the morality or "goodness" of competing religions, you have to appeal to something outside the religious structure, using a non-theistic criteria like utilitarianism.

Now if you are saying that all religions are "good" that's one thing, but you seem to regard highly the "utility" of a good religion to motivate and respond to the fear of presumably "bad" religions defeating the "good."

But then again perhaps the "bad" religion defeating the "good"/our prefered religion is okay, becasue that's merely carrying out God's will and we will be consoled we convert and forgive the rape and murder of our heathen misguided wives and children.