Harry Potter- round 6-who's ready?

[Alex]

Originally Posted by mousepod

It seems to me that they (the screenwriter, director, whoever) picked some key scenes and lines of dialogue from the book and then just filmed them.

For me, the measure successful adaptation of one art form into another is whether each work can stand on its own.

It's funny because I felt that way about the previous movies but thought they avoided that for the most part this time. Now, I still didn't think the result was all that interesting but I found it much more coherent than the last few.

Maybe my expectations have finally just reached so a low level that it was possible for them to be exceeded.