Lost!

[Eliza Hodgkins 1812]

Originally Posted by Cadaverous Pallor

Heh, bespectacled, bookish teacher Ben would be a fun one. Bloodied tortured not-yet-Ben might get mistaken for any other character.

I still think Charlie is the best because of the costume. Rings, letters written on knuckles, short blond hair, rocker shirt, slashed jeans, maybe a small guitar prop. If you get crafty you could make one of those clay madonnas with little bags inside...

Charlie dressed like a D-bag rocker because he was a D-bag rocker. Boring costume! Unless you apply some sort of wet looking substance, made yourself look a bit blue-ish, and had "NOT PENNY'S BOAT" written on your hand... That would be cool.

I know, go as Charlie's heroine Mary statue!