Shameless plug for a good cause

[€uroMeinke]

I know a Canadian aunt of mine received some cancer treatments in the US, but those were still covered under her Canadian health care.

But surely Canada and the US are not the only two options we have?

[Kevy Baby]

Well, there was an article in the LA Times a couple of weeks back about people traveling to India (at least I think it was India) for good surgery at cheap prices. Couldn't find anything in a quick search of their site though.

[sleepyjeff]

Originally Posted by Kevy Baby

Well, there was an article in the LA Times a couple of weeks back about people traveling to India (at least I think it was India) for good surgery at cheap prices. Couldn't find anything in a quick search of their site though.

I had a customer buy a mattress from me to take with her to India for surgery a couple of years ago.

[€uroMeinke]

At least the India example is a model that makes sense, a certain quality level at a more competitive price.

The insurance model is whacked, I agree with Prudence that the insurance company incentive is to deny coverage. The gatekeeper role is they play is a huge pain in the ass as anyone whose dealt with it knows. But even the programs intended to mitigate are difficult to deal with. I have a health care reimbursement account, I contribute pretax dollars for health care expenses, but sometimes getting them to pay is like pulling teeth. Or weird things like the Insurance not paying because they didn't receive a bill from the MD office in 90 days - hey if insurance doesn't have to pay under those conditions why should I? For god's sake we're already funding a huge bureaucracy - can we somehow kill that one without building another?

OK, I'm venting now over my own frustrations with the existing system. I don't know what the solution is, but this can't be the best way of doing things.

[scaeagles]

Canadians Waiting Longer for Medical Treatment in 2006 According to Annual Survey

From the article -

The amount of time Canadians have to wait for surgical and other therapeutic treatment increased slightly in 2006 and continued to hover near the 18 week mark

and....

Canadians should not expect to see any dramatic improvement in waiting times as a result of the latest federal-provincial agreements regarding waiting lists. The long waiting times for medically necessary services are a symptom of a much greater problem: a poorly designed health care system.

Waiting for medical services in Canada: lots of heat, but little light

Canadians' long-standing approval of their health care system declined significantly during the 1990s. While 61% of respondents to a 1991 Angus Reid poll rated the system "excellent" or "very good," that figure had fallen to 52% by 1995, and was just 24% in 1999.1

The problems are immense. Not anecdotal in the least.

[Motorboat Cruiser]

Originally Posted by scaeagles

The problems are immense. Not anecdotal in the least.

Interesting to note that in Denmark and Finland, roughly 80-90 percent of the people are satisfied with their (universal) health care. In America, 40% are satisfied. So, perhaps the Canadian model isn't our only option.

Here is an interesting study: US Healthcare System: Best in the world or just most expensive?

For the record, the link is a PDF file.

[Kevy Baby]

Oh fine; just muck things up with the facts

[Strangler Lewis]

As I recall the story, it was about employer health plans requiring people to go to India for their surgery. It may be irrational, but I'd take a lot of convincing that I'd be just as likely to come out alive over there as at UCSF.

[tracilicious]

Originally Posted by Strangler Lewis

As I recall the story, it was about employer health plans requiring people to go to India for their surgery. It may be irrational, but I'd take a lot of convincing that I'd be just as likely to come out alive over there as at UCSF.

I'm always baffled why people put so much stock in our healthcare system. Is it because we are American therefore making whatever we do the best? Is it because we are one of the richest countries in the world, so logically our healthcare system should be the best?

Having a baby? Congratulations! You're baby would be more likely to survive it's first year of life in 35 other countries. (Granted, this is due as much to cultural practices as it is Medical, but still.)

It wouldn't surprise me in the least if the rest of our medical system was just as subpar. Our dental association just now recognized that mercury in fillings may be damaging to your health. Nearly every other industrialized country eliminated them years ago. I'm sure there are loads of examples just like that.

[flippyshark]

Well, Kevy Baby is the one who brought Canada specifically into the discussion, so I guess it's okay if he dances on the grave of that particular sidebar.

This topic seems on the verge of reaching the endless barking circle stage, so, I'm signing off of it, left wondering along with a lot of others, is our current system the best we can do?