The Oscars

[innerSpaceman]

But, wow, I love the way that acronym looks!

[Alex]

And NA is right about the second being better. Just not a particularly creative effort.

But I also don't have a problem with remakes. You just don't get full creative credit.

[€uroMeinke]

Originally Posted by innerSpaceman

But, wow, I love the way that acronym looks!

Indeed - someone needs to make it into a Disney attraction

[Cadaverous Pallor]

Originally Posted by €uroMeinke

Indeed - someone needs to make it into a Disney attraction

Perhaps they could put it in the WWTBAMPI! building

[Not Afraid]

So, what about films based on books? Is that any different/better/worse?

[Alex]

Originally Posted by Not Afraid

So, what about films based on books? Is that any different/better/worse?

I addressed that up above:

Originally Posted by by me up above

but one big difference, I think, is that with a filmed remake of another film you are provided not just with story or specific dialog but also camera angles, editing decisions, pacing, staging, etc. You can pick what has already worked on film once while tweaking what has already been shown to not. In other words, while those other sources help with story they don't necessary help with the cinematic parts.

Who gets more creative credit? The director who is brought it by a producer to make an already cast movie based on a screenplay adapted from a successful stage production or the guy who writes a script, casts it, fights off studio interference and directs it exactly the way he envisioned it in his head?

The latter. That doesn't mean he made a better movie, though.

[Not Afraid]

Originally Posted by Alex Stroup

I addressed that up above:



Who gets more creative credit? The director who is brought it by a producer to make an already cast movie based on a screenplay adapted from a successful stage production or the guy who writes a script, casts it, fights off studio interference and directs it exactly the way he envisioned it in his head?

The latter. That doesn't mean he made a better movie, though.

Thanks. I obviously missed that part. Bathroom break or something.

[Gemini Cricket]

Originally Posted by mousepod

TMWKTM

Originally Posted by Not Afraid

MITLF

Originally Posted by Cadaverous Pallor

WWTBAMPI!

I demand to know what you cuckoo birds are saying.
:bangs table with fist Cadaverous Pallor style:


Edit: Never mind, Cuckoo Birds. Me scroll 'em up higher and figure out. Ugh. ~ Chief Dances with Crickets

[mousepod]

Yes, the remake of TMWKTM brought us "Que Sera Sera," but we lost Peter Lorre. I like the original.

[Not Afraid]

It sure is better than MITLF