Lost!

[Eliza Hodgkins 1812]

Is there also general agreement that Lockeness wasn't telling Jack the truth about Jack's dad, Christian? Because Lockeness cannot cross the water (he's trapped on the island and they've listed off his restrictions, etc.), but Christian appeared to Michael on the boat, and he appeared to Jack at the hospital, after Jack was rescued. So...methinks Lockeness is a liar.

[sleepyjeff]

Originally Posted by Eliza Hodgkins 1812

Is there also general agreement that Lockeness wasn't telling Jack the truth about Jack's dad, Christian? Because Lockeness cannot cross the water (he's trapped on the island and they've listed off his restrictions, etc.), but Christian appeared to Michael on the boat, and he appeared to Jack at the hospital, after Jack was rescued. So...methinks Lockeness is a liar.

At this late date one would think that big reveals like this should be the truth...but something doesn't add up....either Lockeness can move accross water and lied about that, he's lying and has never impersonated Christian, or he was telling the truth and has sometimes impersonated Christian.

Another funny thing though.....in both Locke and Christians case, MiB needed their bodies to impersonate them.....when he impersonated Eko's brother, there was a body also.....but how did he impersonate Richards wife on board the Black Rock?????

Kate's horse?


Something tells me MiB isn't the only one doing this.....

[Eliza Hodgkins 1812]

Originally Posted by sleepyjeff

At this late date one would think that big reveals like this should be the truth...but something doesn't add up....either Lockeness can move accross water and lied about that, he's lying and has never impersonated Christian, or he was telling the truth and has sometimes impersonated Christian.

Another funny thing though.....in both Locke and Christians case, MiB needed their bodies to impersonate them.....when he impersonated Eko's brother, there was a body also.....but how did he impersonate Richards wife on board the Black Rock?????

Kate's horse?


Something tells me MiB isn't the only one doing this.....

Well, there are ghosts, too. Hurley saw Richard's wife, so maybe that really was Richard's wife. Heh. Who the eff knows.

[Ghoulish Delight]

Perhaps he doesn't need the body to simply impersonate someone, but needs the body to leave the island. Ilana implicated that by becoming Locke, MIB "trapped" himself, indicating that perhaps this incarnation is different than previous shapeshifting he's done.

[sleepyjeff]

Originally Posted by Eliza Hodgkins 1812

Well, there are ghosts, too. Hurley saw Richard's wife, so maybe that really was Richard's wife. Heh. Who the eff knows.

I think it is pretty well established that it was indeed Richards wife that Hurley was talking too.....but when Richard was in chains.......who the eff knows

Originally Posted by Ghoulish Delight

Perhaps he doesn't need the body to simply impersonate someone, but needs the body to leave the island. Ilana implicated that by becoming Locke, MIB "trapped" himself, indicating that perhaps this incarnation is different than previous shapeshifting he's done.

Yes, I think it must be something along those lines......who the eff really knows though

[Eliza Hodgkins 1812]

Originally Posted by sleepyjeff

I think it is pretty well established that it was indeed Richards wife that Hurley was talking too.....but when Richard was in chains.......who the eff knows

Sorry, I meant that because Hurley saw the real wife, maybe Richard saw his real wife, too.

[sleepyjeff]

Originally Posted by Eliza Hodgkins 1812

Sorry, I meant that because Hurley saw the real wife, maybe Richard saw his real wife, too.

Could be, it's just that why would a ghost pretend to be attacked?



My next puzzlement:

What was Widmore trying to accomplish with the bombardment of Team Flocke?

1) I don't think bombs really hurt this thing....

2) If Widmore is just trying to kill Flockes followers; why use non-lethal tranquilizers when taking Jin?

3) Could he have been trying to kill Jack?

[katiesue]

Originally Posted by sleepyjeff

3) Could he have been trying to kill Jack?

I thought what's her name (I'm horrible with names) Widmore chick said something like "if you've got a line on Locke use it". Then they bombed em.

[JWBear]

I think she said "If you have a lock on my position..."

[Ghoulish Delight]

Originally Posted by JWBear

I think she said "If you have a lock on my position..."

That's what she said when she showed up in Locke's camp and they bombed near it to scare him. But at the end of the episode when they fired again nearly hitting Locke and Jack she said "If you've got line of sight on Locke".