Thread: The Official Harry Potter thread (SPOILERS - NO tags)
View Single Post
Old 07-24-2005, 12:18 AM   #2
BarTopDancer
Prepping...
 
BarTopDancer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Here, there, everywhere
Posts: 11,405
BarTopDancer is the epitome of coolBarTopDancer is the epitome of coolBarTopDancer is the epitome of coolBarTopDancer is the epitome of coolBarTopDancer is the epitome of coolBarTopDancer is the epitome of coolBarTopDancer is the epitome of coolBarTopDancer is the epitome of coolBarTopDancer is the epitome of coolBarTopDancer is the epitome of coolBarTopDancer is the epitome of cool
I would agree with you WB except...

Spoiler:
JKR has said in interviews that death is permanent and forever. She doesn't want to confuse the kiddos that their loved ones may come back.


That said I think:

Spoiler:
He is dead but will come back in some form to help Harry. I also think that he and Snape were in on it together, that Snape really is a double agent, on the side of Dumbledore to help Harry. I think when Dumbledore was begging he wasn't begging for his life, but for Snape to kill him for the greater good.


Oops! Stupid submit button.

Uber major theory ahead re: red herrings:
Spoiler:
JRK is the Queen of red herrings. Does anyone else think that Harry is the ultimate red herring? Or is that just sleep deprivation talking.


Thank you and goodnight!
__________________
Spork is the new MacGyver
BarTopDancer is offline   Submit to Quotes Reply With Quote