The Official Harry Potter thread (SPOILERS - NO tags)

[BarTopDancer]

I would agree with you WB except...

Spoiler:

JKR has said in interviews that death is permanent and forever. She doesn't want to confuse the kiddos that their loved ones may come back.

That said I think:

Spoiler:

He is dead but will come back in some form to help Harry. I also think that he and Snape were in on it together, that Snape really is a double agent, on the side of Dumbledore to help Harry. I think when Dumbledore was begging he wasn't begging for his life, but for Snape to kill him for the greater good.

Oops! Stupid submit button.

Uber major theory ahead re: red herrings:

Spoiler:

JRK is the Queen of red herrings. Does anyone else think that Harry is the ultimate red herring? Or is that just sleep deprivation talking.

Thank you and goodnight!