Lost!

[BarTopDancer]

Originally Posted by Eliza Hodgkins 1812

Also, when he warned Frenchie about the whispers, I thought it was more threat than out of consideration for her safety. He said, "If you want your daughter to live," which I took to mean that if Rosseau followed the whispers as a way to find her daughter, they would kill her daughter. I don't know. I've been wrong many times about this show.

I did not think of the comment in that light. Perhaps it was a threat.

And what are those whispers? Where do they come from? What are they saying?

Originally Posted by Pirate Bill

I'm having trouble thinking of someone Ben killed or had killed who Smokey would not judge to be bad or bad for the island. I'm not saying Ben was justified in killing off the Dharma folks or that they were bad people deserving of death. Just that it's probably what the island wanted, by Smokey's judgement.

Perhaps we have yet to learn what "bad things" Dharma has done. We know they lied to Ben's father about what they needed him on the island for. Maybe they killed puppies.

[sleepyjeff]

Originally Posted by BarTopDancer

Perhaps we have yet to learn what "bad things" Dharma has done. We know they lied to Ben's father about what they needed him on the island for. Maybe they killed puppies.

"But you'll also have to watch out for mass murderers, serial killers, torturers and. . .puppy kickers."

~Daria to her sister Quinn~
Daria