On the subject of Goofy

[innerSpaceman]

True ... but, c'mon ... he doesn't have the face of a tan coonhound. With all due respect to the O.P., that's quite a stretch. (Heheh, he probably spoiler-tagged the comparison images for a reason. They don't pan out as a match ... sorry).


Goofy's history as man, horse, dog and dog-faced man is quite the genesis. Seeing as my conversation with Art Babbit happened when hindsight was likely 93% of his sight ... I'll grant that his analysis was a wrap-up of the Goof's tortured history. I don't see how that makes a difference. No one claims Goofy's a horse just because he was one at some distant point.

But the fact remains that the Goofy established as a major character was not a dog. He existed in the same immediate world as Pluto ... and even allowing for cartoon reality, it just doesn't gel that both characters are dogs.

Synopsis or not, the man who - by and large - was Goofy's creator told me in his own words. No better or further truth can be found.

[Ghoulish Delight]

Originally Posted by innerSpaceman

True ... but, c'mon ... he doesn't have the face of a tan coonhound. With all due respect to the O.P., that's quite a stretch. (Heheh, he probably spoiler-tagged the comparison images for a reason. They don't pan out as a match ... sorry).

I spoilered it because they took up too much space.

And, as Alex said, even if he is a "dog-faced man" and not a dog, that dog-face was patterned after something.

Unfortunately, the best drawing of Goofy I found on the 'net that showed the similarities wouldn't show up properly. Say what you want, but CP and I took one look at the dog's ears and face on the dog show and simultaneously came to the same conclusion.


This is just payback for my clock cynicism, isn't it?