Does popular = good?

[Not Afraid]

Originally Posted by Alex

Side Topic A answer: Particularly not when it comes to IMDb movie ratings where geek herd mentality reigns. For example, The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly; Pulp Fiction; The Empire Strikes Back; and The Return of the King are also in IMDb's Top 10.

I'd love to see an analysis of what type of customers IMDB's niche market is composed of. I've never really thought about it being a "geek herd mentality".

Top 10 lists are incredibly subjective and, it seems, the broader the audience the dull the list.

When I look at the All Time USA Box Office list, I don't see much on there that I would put on my "top" list.

AFI's top 100 list is more to my own taste.