Jewish Defence league. Are they really that dumb?

[Moonliner]

Here is what Will Smith said about Hitler:

Originally Posted by Will Smith

Even Hitler didn't wake up going, 'let me do the most evil thing I can do today'," said Will. "I think he woke up in the morning and using a twisted, backwards logic, he set out to do what he thought was 'good'

and the JDL's response:

Originally Posted by JDL.ORG

Smith's comments are ignorant, detestable and offensive. They spit on the memory of every person murdered by the Nazis. His disgusting words stick a knife in the backs of every veteran who fought so valiantly to save the world from those aspirations of Adolf Hitler. Smith's comments also cast the perpetrators of the Holocaust as misguided fellows rather than the repulsive villains of history they truly were.

Can't these folks at the JDL see they are shooting themselves in the foot over this type of thing? What Mr. Smith said is basically TRUE. If you had the chance to interview Hitler and asked, "Mr. Hitler, are you evil?" what do you think his response would have been?

The only one I see being ignorant here is the JDL.

[Morrigoon]

The road to hell is paved with ____ intentions.

[Cadaverous Pallor]

I have to agree, Moonie. Irrational kneejerk response.

[Strangler Lewis]

Originally Posted by Moonliner

If you had the chance to interview Hitler and asked, "Mr. Hitler, are you evil?" what do you think his response would have been?

Probably the same as if you asked him if Jews were fully human.

[Moonliner]

Originally Posted by Strangler Lewis

Probably the same as if you asked him if Jews were fully human.

I expect he would have answered both questions "No."

Am I to read into your response that you think Mr. Smiths comments were somehow pro-Hitler?

[Capt Jack]

just goes to show how an intelligent, well spoken logic based opinion can get you into as much trouble as a really dumb one all depending on who hears it and how they decide to take it

[Jazzman]

Yeah, pretty dumb and uninformed response from them. I can't stand when the truth of history gets obscured by emotions and opinions. It's like people who love conspiracies and dislike the government so they think that bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki was a political move to "scare the Russians." Revisionist history sucks. We're supposed to learn from the past and use it as a lesson in what not to do in the future, but that isn't possible when past events can't be viewed and discussed accurately. It's as though Michael Moore is teaching history in all our schools or something.

[tracilicious]

I really like Will Smith. I would think that the JDL could choose their battles just a little better. Smith is clearly anti-Hitler.

[Strangler Lewis]

Pro-Hitler? No. Anti-semitic? Possibly. Phenomenally stupid? Absolutely.

We all have impulses to cruelty, and Hitler and the Nazis joyfully gave theirs free rein. When someone declares people sub-human, confiscates their property, murders them en masse, including children, harvests their fillings, makes people dig their own mass grave, etc., etc., etc., you don't look back on that with a shrug and say, "Well, he meant well."

[Ghoulish Delight]

No one has published the full context of his quote. The reaction is based on an article author's preface, "Remarkably, Will believes everyone is basically good." What a disgusting twist on a quote with no other context.

Sorry, but all he said was the Hitler himself didn't think what he was doing was evil. Who can possibly dispute that statement? Hitler thought he was doing the right thing. Period.

This "controversy" is pathetic.