Gerard Butler

[Ponine]

No, no.... I didnt like him as the Phantom... I couldnt see your appeal.
What I was trying to say... was that after I saw Timeline... I understood his appeal.

But soley on his performance in Phantom? No way jose.

But.. when i saw PotO live, the Phantom was african-american, and sang like a dream.
Had Gerard sang better, I might have been all over it.

But.... with the longer hair, and the accent, in Timeline..... I'm with ya.
And meh.. Timeline wasnt that bad... better book... but not that bad.