Lost!

[bewitched]

After reading E! online, who the fvck is the person behind and just to the right of Sun (right after the smoke enters) in the room where she's talking to Christian?

[Ghoulish Delight]

I'd have to see, but wouldn't that be Frank?

[sleepyjeff]

Originally Posted by Ghoulish Delight

Don't know if they're in the past or the future, but I'm certain the plane and those who remained on it did travel in time, just not to 1977. Perhaps they are in a period between the purge and when the Others claimed the barracks as their own.

If they did(and I guess they must have at least a little since night did turn into day right before the crash) it couldn't be by more than a year*.....so my question as to why that Dharma stuff is still hanging around remains a valid one.



*1977 plus 30 years equals 2007....Unless we can't even trust the on screen narration

[Ghoulish Delight]

Originally Posted by sleepyjeff

*1977 plus 30 years equals 2007....Unless we can't even trust the on screen narration

Good point. So:

1) alternate reality caused by time travel
2) for some reason there are Dharma sign still around, even though it had been Others' land for so long
3) wrong/misleading info when we're told it was 30 years ago
4) stupid production decision because they wanted to be sure it was obvious where they were.

My guess is option 4.

[sleepyjeff]

Originally Posted by Ghoulish Delight

Good point. So:

1) alternate reality caused by time travel
2) for some reason there are Dharma sign still around, even though it had been Others' land for so long
3) wrong/misleading info when we're told it was 30 years ago
4) stupid production decision because they wanted to be sure it was obvious where they were.

My guess is option 4.

I fear you are probably right.

[bewitched]

Nope, Frank is standing right next to her (on the left). There is someone (it looks like a woman) sitting in the shadows behind and to the right of Sun.

[sleepyjeff]

Originally Posted by bewitched

Nope, Frank is standing right next to her (on the left). There is someone (it looks like a woman) sitting in the shadows behind and to the right of Sun.

I bet it's Claire....she was last seen hanging with her Dad, no reason to be surprised she's still with him.

[bewitched]

They need to make the episodes something more along the lines of 3 hours.


Someone on E! also mentioned Richard saying that the sonic fence couldn't keep them (the Others) out. That would fit nicely with the theory that the Others are all dead and the island is Aaru.

[Ghoulish Delight]

The Others seem to bleed a lot when shot, for being dead.

[bewitched]

Hmmmm, good point. Maybe the ones who got shot are are Dharma people who were assimilated into the Others as Ben was and now Ethan seems to have been? (And thinking about it...it seems as though there's a better than average chance that over the years more than a few people have been shipwrecked and/or crashed on the island, survived and never got off; which also makes me wonder if we'll eventually discover Mr. Eko's brother amongst the Others or hanging out w/ Christian.)

I dunno, but if the Others can get through the fence, there must be something special about them.