Lost!

[Ghoulish Delight]

Originally Posted by bewitched

Wait. NotLocke more or less said he could give Nadia back to Sayid. In the sideways world, Sayid has Nadia back (in a sense). Is the sideways world also MIB's world; one in which he has given people what they want (but maybe not specifically how they thought they would get it)?

NotLocke also told Claire the Others had Aaron. I wouldn't take him at his word.

[bewitched]

Originally Posted by Ghoulish Delight

NotLocke also told Claire the Others had Aaron. I wouldn't take him at his word.

Well, Kate may be considered an "other" now...and she has Aaron (more or less).

In this theory, I don't think MIB is giving out what people want in the way they want it. Kind of like King Midas' wish to be able to turn everything he touched to gold didn't work out quite the way he envisioned.