Lost!

[scaeagles]

OK....maybe I'm not understanding something....

This whole Desmond thing would seem to point to some form of parallel universe kind of thing. Right? Maybe I'm wrong. If that's the case, I'm not sure how the Jacob vs. Smokey and keeping smokey on the island comes into play.

Am I just way off or am I missing some connection?

[Ghoulish Delight]

Originally Posted by scaeagles

OK....maybe I'm not understanding something....

This whole Desmond thing would seem to point to some form of parallel universe kind of thing. Right? Maybe I'm wrong. If that's the case, I'm not sure how the Jacob vs. Smokey and keeping smokey on the island comes into play.

Am I just way off or am I missing some connection?

They have not made it clear, is the answer. Could be parallel universe. Could be that the parallel universe is a "trapped in their own mind" kinda thing (as could the island itself). They have not given enough information to know what the relationship between the island and the flash sideways world is.

[Ghoulish Delight]

Originally Posted by Ghoulish Delight

Loved Eloise's reaction to Desmond's new found knowledge.

Originally Posted by scaeagles

OK....maybe I'm not understanding something....

This whole Desmond thing would seem to point to some form of parallel universe kind of thing. Right? Maybe I'm wrong. If that's the case, I'm not sure how the Jacob vs. Smokey and keeping smokey on the island comes into play.

Am I just way off or am I missing some connection?

Originally Posted by Ghoulish Delight

They have not made it clear, is the answer. Could be parallel universe. Could be that the parallel universe is a "trapped in their own mind" kinda thing (as could the island itself). They have not given enough information to know what the relationship between the island and the flash sideways world is.

Based on Eloise's reaction, it's looking more and more like this is some sort of virtual reality experiment. Matrix/holodeck kinda thing. In that context I suppose that the MIB/Jacob dynamic might represent the suspension of disbelief necessary to keep the illusion. That, like the Matrix, for the VR environment to remain stable and convincing, the participants need to have free will, which carries the risk of destroying the whole experiment. And what's left undetermined is, would blowing the experiment open be a good thing or a bad thing. Perhaps the VR world is an alternate to some unpleasant reality and it's all for their own good. Or perhaps it's a punishment of some sort.

[Eliza Hodgkins 1812]

Originally Posted by Ghoulish Delight

Based on Eloise's reaction, it's looking more and more like this is some sort of virtual reality experiment. Matrix/holodeck kinda thing. In that context I suppose that the MIB/Jacob dynamic might represent the suspension of disbelief necessary to keep the illusion. That, like the Matrix, for the VR environment to remain stable and convincing, the participants need to have free will, which carries the risk of destroying the whole experiment. And what's left undetermined is, would blowing the experiment open be a good thing or a bad thing. Perhaps the VR world is an alternate to some unpleasant reality and it's all for their own good. Or perhaps it's a punishment of some sort.

Excited and interested in this theory, and I suppose I won't even be mildly disappointed if this is all a much better way of handling that kind of story than the film "eXistenZ".

Also, I should probably read "The Third Policeman" before this show ends. I've been meaning to do that but keep getting sidetracked by other books.

[Ghoulish Delight]

Originally Posted by Eliza Hodgkins 1812

Excited and interested in this theory, and I suppose I won't even be mildly disappointed if this is all a much better way of handling that kind of story than the film "eXistenZ".

That movie wanted so badly to be good. It gave it a good shot, but never quite overcame its cheapness/cheesiness.