Toy Story 3

[Strangler Lewis]

If they were going to depict the idea of torture, setting up a world in which torture=being played with by unimaginative two-year-olds and not-torture=being played with by imaginative three-year-olds, they did not do a good job in setting up the dramatic conflict. I kept thinking, "suck it up, toys."

That this assignment was eminently suckupable is borne out by the concluding montage in which all the remaining toys share the load of playing with the smaller children.

As to the point about Bonnie, was she truly the only not-Andy who deserved to inherit all the toys? Giving Woody to her might have been a nice moment. Giving her the whole box seemed indulgent.

[Alex]

Originally Posted by Strangler Lewis

If they were going to depict the idea of torture, setting up a world in which torture=being played with by unimaginative two-year-olds and not-torture=being played with by imaginative three-year-olds, they did not do a good job in setting up the dramatic conflict. I kept thinking, "suck it up, toys."

That this assignment was eminently suckupable is borne out by the concluding montage in which all the remaining toys share the load of playing with the smaller children.

Except it wasn't just that they had to be played with by kids too young it was that they'd only be played with by kids to young and at the same time denied the respit and repair that would allow them to survive it. It wasn't that being stuck in that room meant years of hard play it was that being stuck in that room meant months of being destroyed until you were simply thrown in the trash.

I thought it did a fine job setting up why that was a situation that needed to be escaped, but if it didn't work for you, it didn't work.

[Alex]

Originally Posted by Strangler Lewis

As to the point about Bonnie, was she truly the only not-Andy who deserved to inherit all the toys?

Probably not. But how many other not-Andys does Woody know? Andy didn't pick her for donating the toys, Woody did. That's what was on the note, not just "give us away" but "Give us to Bonnie at Address X" (Woody knew the address from earlier when they use Google Maps).