What's good for the goose...

scaeagles · 11-07-2005, 03:35 PM

I do remember that. But here's what I don't get......

To be Catholic, and a Catholic in good standing, means to abide by the principles and teachings of the church, correct? So is it political to deny Kerry communion because simply because he is in political office and seeking the Presidency? Or is it treating him like they would any other member of the church who supported abortion rights?

What is happening is that the tax exempt status of churches is being held over their heads. No, they may not endorse candidates and I fully support that. But to operate within their own guidelines by preaching on an issue in the public square is fully within their rights. To operate within their own rules - such as denying communion to Kerry because of his pro choice stand - is perfectly legit. To offer biblical or (insert your favorite religious text here) opinions and teachings as to the current state of political affairs and events is something for the church to do. I say keep the hands of the government off the church. Separation works both ways. (That being said, I am not one who thinks that "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion" means the two must be mutually exclusive.)

11-07-2005, 03:35 PM	#8
scaeagles I LIKE! Join Date: Jan 2005 Posts: 7,819	I do remember that. But here's what I don't get...... To be Catholic, and a Catholic in good standing, means to abide by the principles and teachings of the church, correct? So is it political to deny Kerry communion because simply because he is in political office and seeking the Presidency? Or is it treating him like they would any other member of the church who supported abortion rights? What is happening is that the tax exempt status of churches is being held over their heads. No, they may not endorse candidates and I fully support that. But to operate within their own guidelines by preaching on an issue in the public square is fully within their rights. To operate within their own rules - such as denying communion to Kerry because of his pro choice stand - is perfectly legit. To offer biblical or (insert your favorite religious text here) opinions and teachings as to the current state of political affairs and events is something for the church to do. I say keep the hands of the government off the church. Separation works both ways. (That being said, I am not one who thinks that "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion" means the two must be mutually exclusive.)
	Submit to Quotes