Tookie Williams denied clemency

Alex · 12-13-2005, 12:57 PM

That quote is meaninless as it could be extended to prohibit just about any action by society against the individual.

I have no problem saying that some people should be put to death, I just don't have sufficient faith in a bureaucracy to be sufficiently accurate or consistent in making that determination.

When I am master of the universe (a process that can't start until I get around to bleaching my hair), there will be a death penalty.

innerSpaceman · 12-13-2005, 03:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alex Stroup

That quote is meaninless as it could be extended to prohibit just about any action by society against the individual.

Meaningless???!??

Gandalf the Grey - meaningless?!?!? Those Sir, are words of ignorance.

In all seriousness though, I don't see how that can be expanded to include any act. Oh, you can expand that philosophy indefinately if you want, but it's clearly not the intention of Gandalf or Tolkien or Mr. Cricket that you do so. No one, not the Istari nor anyone else, is claiming that denying the state the purview over human life is akin to denying the state the purview over, say, taxes.

Alex · 12-13-2005, 04:47 PM

It extends itself through the logic underpinning the quote. Also it is fallacious in establishing a false connection between giving and taking life.

innerSpaceman · 12-13-2005, 05:06 PM

There is no false connection alluded to in the quote. The very point of the quote is that it's a true connection.

I suppose those who would still instill the death penalty throughout the universe should they be elected God in the next deification election might think the connection false, but that does not change the validity of a quote authored by a non-candidate.

12-13-2005, 12:57 PM	#1
Alex . Join Date: Feb 2005 Posts: 13,354	That quote is meaninless as it could be extended to prohibit just about any action by society against the individual. I have no problem saying that some people should be put to death, I just don't have sufficient faith in a bureaucracy to be sufficiently accurate or consistent in making that determination. When I am master of the universe (a process that can't start until I get around to bleaching my hair), there will be a death penalty.
	Submit to Quotes

12-13-2005, 04:47 PM	#3
Alex . Join Date: Feb 2005 Posts: 13,354	It extends itself through the logic underpinning the quote. Also it is fallacious in establishing a false connection between giving and taking life.
	Submit to Quotes

12-13-2005, 05:06 PM	#4
innerSpaceman Kink of Swank Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Inner Space Posts: 13,075	There is no false connection alluded to in the quote. The very point of the quote is that it's a true connection. I suppose those who would still instill the death penalty throughout the universe should they be elected God in the next deification election might think the connection false, but that does not change the validity of a quote authored by a non-candidate.
	Submit to Quotes