Roland Emmerich doing The Foundation Trilogy

[JWBear]

If there was any literary work that I would consider unfilmable, it would be Foundation. It'll be a train wreck!

[Moonliner]

Originally Posted by JWBear

If there was any literary work that I would consider unfilmable, it would be Foundation. It'll be a train wreck!

Unfimable? From what point of view. Visually I don't see any real problems with today's effects wizards. From a story point of view, the fact that you have an entirely new set of characters every few chapters could be problematic to the studio exec/marketing types.

Off hand I can't think of any movies where each act has an entirely different cast (unless you count Sheldon).

I think the biggest issue might be it's perceived lack of originality since many of it's themes have been copied....

Corisant = Trantor, etc....

[Moonliner]

Oh and just to put everone at ease, I just ran across this....

Emmerich is going to film Foundation in 3D, because Avatar showed you can charge more for 3D movies.

*Whew*

I feel better about this already.

Emmerich said he's looking forward to a new challenge at this point in his career. "Probably now all big movies have to be 3-D," he said. "It's not only the effect of 3-D, ['Avatar' has] just shown that if you do a movie in 3-D, you can ask for more money and that's the trick. I think now everybody who does bigger movies has to shoot them in 3-D. I think there's no way around it. I was on the set of 'Avatar' and I saw how it worked and I really thought, 'That's the ultimate way of making movies.' "

[JWBear]

Originally Posted by Moonliner

Unfimable? From what point of view. Visually I don't see any real problems with today's effects wizards. From a story point of view, the fact that you have an entirely new set of characters every few chapters could be problematic to the studio exec/marketing types.

Off hand I can't think of any movies where each act has an entirely different cast (unless you count Sheldon).

I think the biggest issue might be it's perceived lack of originality since many of it's themes have been copied....

Corisant = Trantor, etc....

OK... Let me rephrase... I can't see how you could make a film (or films) that is/are faithful to the series and wouldn't confuse the hell out of the majority of the movie going public.

[Tref]

Originally Posted by JWBear

It'll be a train wreck!

Having watched the previews of 2012 I can tell you a train wreck is something Emmerich can handle.

[Moonliner]

I wonder if it will be like I-Robot where the only similarity to the book was the title.

[JWBear]

Originally Posted by Moonliner

I wonder if it will be like I-Robot where the only similarity to the book was the title.

It wouldn't surprise me.

[Moonliner]

Update!

No, I don't have one. I'd like one. I used a little Google-Foo and as far as I can tell this movie seems to be making zero progress. All I could find was word that the movie Roland was supposed to be working on for Sony (Singularity) was put on hold after his last movie bombed at the box office.