Lost!

[BarTopDancer]

Originally Posted by Ghoulish Delight

She said "her father"? I missed that. When Jin first asked her if she'd been alone, she said, "No, I was with my friend". Then when somked lox arrived she said, "This is my friend". I never heard "father".

Two different sentences - one was that her "father" told her who took Aaron. The other was she was "with my friend".

It is possible that Christian was MIB when they all left. For all we know, if Smoky wasn't stuck in Locke form now (done for a purpose obviously) he'd still shapeshift into Christian. But Smoky is stuck in Lockeform from now until they tell us otherwise - which I don't think will happen since IIlana (that's her name!) said he can't change anymore.